Part 5 · Chapter 34
BLDC vs PMSM: what is the difference?
A BLDC motor and a PMSM are both three-phase permanent-magnet machines. The difference is in the back-EMF waveform and the drive: a BLDC has a trapezoidal back-EMF and is driven by six-step (trapezoidal) commutation from Hall sensors, while a PMSM has a sinusoidal back-EMF and is driven by sinusoidal currents, usually with field-oriented control.
What they have in common
Both motors have a stator with a three-phase winding and a rotor with permanent magnets. Both need an electronic inverter, because there is no brush or commutator. Both are efficient, because there is no rotor current and so no rotor copper loss, and both have a high power density.
The two names describe the winding and drive conventions more than the physical construction, and in practice a manufacturer's motor can be run either way, with different results.
Back-EMF waveform and current
The back-EMF shape is the main difference.
- BLDC: concentrated windings and magnet shape give a trapezoidal back-EMF with flat tops of 120 electrical degrees. Rectangular current blocks, two phases at a time, line up with those flat tops and give nearly constant torque.
- PMSM: distributed windings and shaped magnets give a sinusoidal back-EMF, matched by sinusoidal phase currents that produce smooth torque at all times.
The back-EMF also sets the torque constant, and the back-EMF itself is explained in the guide on back-EMF and motor constants.
Control: six-step vs FOC
- BLDC drives use six-step commutation: three Hall sensors give six rotor positions per electrical revolution, and at each step two of the three phases conduct. The guide on BLDC commutation shows the sequence.
- PMSM drives use field-oriented control (FOC): a position sensor (encoder or resolver) or an estimator gives the rotor angle, and the controller regulates the d- and q-axis currents. See the guide on PMSM field-oriented control.
FOC needs more computation, a better sensor and current measurements, but delivers smoother torque, lower noise and better efficiency at low speed. Six-step needs only cheap sensors and simple logic.
Worked example: commutation rate
Take a motor with 4 pole pairs (8 poles) running at 3000 rpm, which is 50 rev/s.
1. Electrical frequency: . 2. A six-step BLDC drive commutates 6 times per electrical cycle: commutations per second, one every 0.83 ms. 3. Each step covers 60 electrical degrees, which is of mechanical rotation. 4. The same PMSM under FOC instead updates the voltage vector continuously, typically at the PWM frequency of 10–20 kHz.
The synchronous speed relation gives rpm, the same result.
Which one should you choose?
- Choose a BLDC drive for cost-sensitive products such as fans, pumps, drones and power tools, where a little torque ripple does not matter.
- Choose a PMSM with FOC for servo drives, traction, robotics and anything needing smooth, quiet torque or precise position control.
- Many modern motors are sold as one type but can be driven either way. The trapezoidal drive extracts a bit more torque from a flat-top back-EMF, and the sinusoidal drive extracts more from a sinusoidal one.
The wider picture is in the guide on choosing a motor.
Try it in the simulators
Open the BLDC motor simulator and watch the Hall code change every 60 electrical degrees. Then open the PMSM simulator and change the supply frequency to see the synchronous speed and the load angle. Compare how the two present speed and torque.
Sources and further reading
- T. J. E. Miller, "Brushless Permanent-Magnet and Reluctance Motor Drives", Oxford University Press.
- T. Kenjo and S. Nagamori, "Permanent-Magnet and Brushless DC Motors", Oxford University Press.
- Microchip application note AN885, "Brushless DC (BLDC) Motor Fundamentals".
Try it in the simulator
Frequently asked questions
- What is the difference between BLDC and PMSM?
- A BLDC motor has a trapezoidal back-EMF and is driven by six-step commutation with Hall sensors. A PMSM has a sinusoidal back-EMF and is driven by sinusoidal currents, usually with field-oriented control.
- Can I run a BLDC motor with FOC?
- Yes, many BLDC motors can be run with sinusoidal drive or FOC, which makes the torque smoother, although a trapezoidal back-EMF does not match a sinusoidal current perfectly.
- Which is more efficient, BLDC or PMSM?
- Both are very efficient. A PMSM under FOC usually has lower torque ripple and losses at low speed, while six-step control is simpler and works well at high speed.
- Does a BLDC motor need Hall sensors?
- Six-step control needs the rotor position every 60 electrical degrees, which is usually supplied by three Hall sensors. Sensorless methods estimate it from the back-EMF instead.