Curvo Studio

Part 4 · Chapter 27

Synchronous motor: load angle, pull-out torque and V curves

A synchronous motor turns at exactly the speed of the rotating stator field, N_s = 120 × f / p, whatever the load. Load only changes the load angle δ between rotor and field, and the DC field current decides whether the motor draws lagging or leading reactive power, which is what a V curve shows.

Constant speed: the rotor locks to the field

The stator of a three-phase synchronous motor is wound like that of an induction motor and produces a rotating field at

Ns=120×f/pN_s = 120 \times f / p

The rotor carries a DC-excited field winding (fed through two slip rings and brushes) or permanent magnets, so it is a magnet of fixed polarity. A rotating magnet is pulled around by the rotating stator field and locks to it, like two hands held together while one turns.

There is no slip. A 4-pole motor on 50 Hz turns at 1500 rpm at no load and at full load alike. Mechanical load does not slow the rotor; it makes the rotor lag the field by a larger angle. Speed can only be changed by changing the supply frequency.

Load angle and the power equation

In the per-phase model the motor is a supply voltage VV opposed by an internal (excitation) voltage EfE_f produced by the rotor field, with a synchronous reactance XsX_s between them. The angle by which EfE_f lags VV is the load angle δ\delta. For a round-rotor machine with negligible stator resistance, the power drawn is

P=3×V×Ef×sin⁡δ/XsP = 3 \times V \times E_f \times \sin \delta / X_s

with V and EfE_f as phase voltages. Torque is PP divided by the synchronous angular speed.

At no load δ\delta is near zero. As the shaft load grows, δ\delta grows and the motor takes more power from the supply. The maximum power occurs at δ=90∘\delta = 90^\circ:

Pmax=3×V×Ef/XsP_{\mathrm{max}} = 3 \times V \times E_f / X_s

This is the pull-out (breakdown) power. Beyond it the electrical torque falls as δ\delta increases further, the rotor cannot keep up and the motor loses synchronism. Stable operation is therefore only on the rising part of the curve, below 90°, and in practice engineers keep δ\delta well below it, typically well below 40° at full load, to leave a margin for transients.

Because PmaxP_{\mathrm{max}} is proportional to EfE_f, raising the field current raises the pull-out torque. It is also proportional to VV, so a voltage dip lowers the margin.

V curves, excitation and power-factor correction

At constant shaft power, the in-phase component of the armature current is fixed, because it carries the real power. What the field current changes is the reactive component:

  • Under-excited (EfE_f small): the motor takes lagging current from the grid, like an induction motor or an inductor.
  • Normal excitation: the current is purely in phase with VV, the power factor is unity and the current is at its minimum.
  • Over-excited (EfE_f large): the motor takes leading current, so it behaves like a capacitor and delivers reactive power to the grid.

If you plot armature current against field current at constant load, you get a V-shaped curve with its minimum at unity power factor. Each load has its own V, and heavier loads give higher curves whose minimum sits at a higher field current. Joining the minima gives the unity-power-factor line. The left side of each VV is lagging, the right side is leading.

At heavy load the left side of the VV ends where the field is too weak to hold synchronism, because a weak field means a low PmaxP_{\mathrm{max}}.

Most industrial loads (induction motors, transformers) draw lagging current. An over-excited synchronous motor draws leading current, so it can drive a load and, at the same time, supply the reactive power the other machines need. This raises the plant power factor, reduces line current and losses, and can reduce utility penalties.

A synchronous motor running with no mechanical load, only to supply or absorb reactive power, is called a synchronous condenser (or synchronous compensator). Because its excitation is adjustable, it can be set to generate or absorb reactive power continuously, which large grids use for voltage support.

The cost is the exciter, the slip rings and brushes (or a brushless exciter), and the extra copper loss in the field winding.

Worked example

Take a four-pole, 50 Hz, three-phase motor on a 400 V line (V=230 VV = 230\,\mathrm{V} per phase) with Xs=2 ΩX_s = 2\,\mathrm{\Omega} per phase, carrying 50 kW of electrical power. Ignore resistance.

1. Speed: Ns=120×50/4=1500 rpmN_s = 120 \times 50 / 4 = 1500\,\mathrm{rpm}, independent of load. 2. In-phase current: Ip=50 000/(3×230)≈72.5I_p = 50\,000 / (3 \times 230) \approx 72.5 A. This is fixed at constant power. 3. The quantity Ef×sin⁡δE_f \times \sin \delta must equal P×Xs/(3×V)=50 000×2/690≈145 VP \times X_s / (3 \times V) = 50\,000 \times 2 / 690 \approx 145\,\mathrm{V}.

Now vary the excitation voltage EfE_f:

  • Ef=200 VE_f = 200\,\mathrm{V}: sin⁡δ=145/200\sin \delta = 145 / 200, δ≈46∘\delta \approx 46^\circ. The reactive current is (Efcos⁡δ−V)/Xs≈−46(E_f \cos \delta - V) / X_s \approx -46 A, so the motor is under-excited. Armature current ≈ 86 A, power factor ≈ 0.84 lagging.
  • Ef≈272 VE_f \approx 272\,\mathrm{V}: sin⁡δ=0.53\sin \delta = 0.53, δ≈32∘\delta \approx 32^\circ, reactive current ≈ 0. Armature current ≈ 72.5 A, unity power factor. This is the bottom of the VV.
  • Ef=300 VE_f = 300\,\mathrm{V}: δ≈29∘\delta \approx 29^\circ, reactive current ≈ +16 A. Armature current ≈ 74 A, power factor ≈ 0.98 leading.

Pull-out power at Ef=300 VE_f = 300\,\mathrm{V} is 3×230×300/2≈103.5 kW3 \times 230 \times 300 / 2 \approx 103.5\,\mathrm{kW}, about twice the load, so the motor has a comfortable margin. At Ef=200 VE_f = 200\,\mathrm{V} it is only 69 kW.

Starting: why a synchronous motor cannot start itself

At standstill the stator field sweeps past the rotor at synchronous speed. The rotor, with its inertia, cannot accelerate fast enough to lock on: the torque alternates between forward and backward and averages zero. A synchronous motor therefore has no net starting torque on its own.

The usual fix is a damper (amortisseur) winding, a cage of bars in the pole faces. The motor starts as an induction motor with the field winding unexcited (often closed through a discharge resistor), accelerates to about 95% of synchronous speed, then the DC field is applied and the rotor pulls into step. Other methods are a small pony motor, or a variable-frequency drive that raises the stator frequency from zero so that the rotor can follow.

How the simulator models the synchronous motor

The simulator treats the motor as a round-rotor machine per phase, V=Ef+j×Xs×IV = E_f + j \times X_s \times I, with XsX_s set to 1.0 per unit of the rated base impedance. The excitation voltage follows the field current with a mild saturation curve, calibrated so that rated field current gives rated voltage, current and power factor.

The power-angle relation sin⁡δ=P×Xs/(3×V×Ef)\sin \delta = P \times X_s / (3 \times V \times E_f) fixes the load angle, and the armature current splits into the in-phase and reactive parts described above. If the load exceeds PmaxP_{\mathrm{max}} the model reports loss of synchronism: the rotor drops out of step, speed falls to zero and no stable operating point is shown.

Simplifications to know about: although the 3D rotor has salient poles, the reluctance torque of saliency is neglected; the model does not solve the swing equation, so there are no hunting oscillations; and saturation applies only to the open-circuit curve. The start-up is a simplified sequence on the damper winding, with the field applied near full speed. It is a teaching model, not a tool for selecting or protecting real machines.

Try it in the synchronous motor simulator

Open the synchronous motor simulator and start from one of the three templates (100, 250 or 500 kW).

  • Move the Field (excitation) current slider. Its hint shows the value that gives unity power factor at the present load. Below it the motor is under-excited (lagging), above it over-excited (leading), and the Reactive power readout changes sign (negative means delivered to the grid).
  • Read the V curves chart (armature current vs. field current) at 0%, 50% and 100% load. The operating point slides along the curve for the present load, and the dashed unity power factor line joins the minima.
  • Raise the mechanical load and watch the Load angle δ\delta and Stability margin readouts, and the point climbing the Power–angle curve.
  • Push the load past 100% and reduce the field current until the loss-of-synchronism warning appears (the chart then shows "Out of step at this field current"). Raise the field current again to restore the margin.
  • Watch the 3D rotor: when locked it follows the field a load angle behind, and the model shows the slip rings, brush gear and a DC excitation supply.

The lesson is that load sets δ\delta, while the field current sets the power factor.

Sources and further reading

  • S. J. Chapman, "Electric Machinery Fundamentals", McGraw-Hill.
  • IEEE Std 115, "Guide for Test Procedures for Synchronous Machines".
  • A. E. Fitzgerald, C. Kingsley and S. D. Umans, "Electric Machinery", McGraw-Hill.

Try it in the simulator

Frequently asked questions

Why does a synchronous motor run at constant speed?
Because the rotor is a magnet locked to the rotating stator field. Speed is set only by the supply frequency and pole count, Ns=120×f/pN_s = 120 \times f / p. Load changes the load angle, not the speed.
What is the load angle of a synchronous motor?
It is the angle δ\delta between the supply voltage and the internal excitation voltage, equivalently how far the rotor lags the rotating field. Power is proportional to sin⁡δ\sin \delta, with the maximum at 90°.
What does a V curve show?
A V curve plots armature current against field current at constant load. The minimum is at unity power factor. To the left the motor is under-excited and lagging, to the right it is over-excited and leading.
What is a synchronous condenser?
A synchronous machine running without mechanical load whose only job is to exchange reactive power with the grid. Over-excited it acts like a capacitor and raises voltage, under-excited it absorbs reactive power.
Why can a synchronous motor not start on its own?
At standstill the rotating field passes the rotor too quickly for it to lock on, so the average torque is zero. Motors start with a damper winding as an induction motor, or with a variable-frequency drive, and are pulled into synchronism near full speed.
What happens if the load exceeds the pull-out torque?
The load angle goes beyond 90°, the electrical torque drops, and the rotor falls out of step. The motor stalls or slips poles with large current pulses unless it is tripped.