Part 4 · Chapter 29
Induction motor vs synchronous motor: key differences
An induction motor runs slightly slower than the rotating field and needs slip to make torque; a synchronous motor locks onto the field and runs at exactly the synchronous speed Ns = 120 f / p whatever the load. The synchronous motor also gives control of power factor, but needs a DC or magnet field and a starting method.
How each one works
Both motors have a three-phase stator that creates a rotating magnetic field. They differ in the rotor.
- Induction motor: the rotor is a cage (or a wound winding) in which currents are induced by the relative motion between rotor and field. The rotor has to lag the field, and the lag is the slip. See the guide on induction motor slip.
- Synchronous motor: the rotor has its own magnetic field, from DC-excited windings or permanent magnets, and it locks to the rotating field. The speed is fixed by the frequency, and the rotor lags by a load angle, not by slip. See the guide on synchronous motor load angle and V curves.
Speed and load
For a 4-pole motor on 50 Hz, rpm for both.
- The induction motor at full load runs at about 1440 rpm (4% slip) and its speed drops as the load rises.
- The synchronous motor runs at exactly 1500 rpm from no load up to the pull-out torque. Beyond pull-out it loses synchronism and stalls.
That constant speed is why synchronous motors drive compressors, mills and clocks, and why a synchronous motor on a variable-frequency drive is a precise speed source. See pull-out torque.
Starting
An induction motor is self-starting: a stationary rotor already has currents induced in it and develops torque. A synchronous motor has no net torque at standstill, because the field rotates faster than a stationary rotor can follow. It needs one of three solutions:
- A damper (amortisseur) cage that makes it start as an induction motor and then pull into synchronism.
- A variable-frequency drive that raises the field speed from zero.
- A small pony motor that brings it up to speed.
See the guide on motor starting methods for the starting hardware that both use.
Power factor: a worked example
An induction motor always draws lagging reactive current to magnetize the air gap, so its power factor is below 1, typically 0.8 to 0.9 at full load. A synchronous motor with DC excitation can be over-excited to run at unity or even a leading power factor, supplying reactive power to the grid.
Worked example: a 100 kW load at a power factor of 0.85 lagging.
1. Apparent power angle: . 2. Reactive power: . 3. A synchronous motor of the same output run at unity power factor draws no reactive power, so the supply no longer carries those 62 kvar, and can be loaded less.
The same effect is behind the V curves, where changing the field current changes the line current and power factor at constant load. See power factor.
Efficiency, cost and where each is used
- Induction motors are simple, rugged and cheap, and dominate industry. They lose some energy in rotor copper, so synchronous machines are somewhat more efficient at the same rating. The IE efficiency classes, covered in the guide on motor losses and efficiency, apply to both.
- Synchronous motors cost more, need an exciter or magnets, and are chosen for large, slow, steady loads, for power factor correction and for precise speed. Permanent-magnet versions are common in drives and electric vehicles.
- With a drive both can be controlled over a wide speed range. See VFD and V/f control.
For a first choice the guide on choosing a motor compares all types.
Try it in the simulators
Open the three-phase induction motor simulator and raise the load while watching the rotor speed fall below 1500 rpm. Then open the wound-field synchronous motor simulator and see that speed stays at the synchronous value while the load angle grows and the field current changes the power factor.
Sources and further reading
- S. J. Chapman, "Electric Machinery Fundamentals", chapters on induction motors and synchronous motors.
- A. E. Fitzgerald, C. Kingsley and S. D. Umans, "Electric Machinery".
- IEC 60034-1, "Rotating electrical machines: Rating and performance".
Try it in the simulator
Frequently asked questions
- What is the main difference between induction and synchronous motors?
- An induction motor runs below synchronous speed, with slip, and its rotor is magnetized by induction. A synchronous motor runs at exactly the synchronous speed because its rotor has its own magnetic field and locks to the rotating field.
- Why is a synchronous motor not self-starting?
- At standstill the field rotates much faster than the rotor can follow, so the average torque is zero. It needs a damper cage, a variable-frequency drive or a pony motor to start.
- Which motor can improve power factor?
- An over-excited synchronous motor can run at unity or leading power factor and supply reactive power. An induction motor always draws lagging reactive current.
- Which is more efficient?
- At the same rating a synchronous motor is typically a little more efficient, because it has no rotor copper loss from induced current, but an induction motor is cheaper and more rugged.